Tax Changes Make Cash Balance Plans Even More Attractive

Small business owners interested in taking advantage of the new 20 percent qualified business income (QBI) deduction under the 2017 tax law should consider taking a look at pairing a cash balance plan with their 401(k).

Qualified Business Income Deduction

While the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 did not address defined benefit plans directly, it did change tax deductions in ways that are certain to make the old-fashioned pension plan much more attractive. One of the most talked about changes to the tax code is the creation of the QBI deduction. This allows the owner of a partnership, sole proprietor, trust or S corp to deduct from his or her taxable income 20 percent of the business’ QBI (subject to limitations). At a top federal tax rate of 37 percent, higher deductions will result in hefty savings.

One catch to this new deduction is business owners in a number of fields – including health, law, sports and performing arts – cannot use QBI if their adjusted gross income (AGI) is too high. For married couples filing jointly, the deduction is phased out from $315,000-$415,000. This drops to $157,500-$207,500 for single filers. Clearly, there is a big incentive for business-owning taxpayers to make AGI fall under the QBI cap.

Here’s where the defined benefit or cash balance plan comes into play. Using a cash balance plan in combination with a 401(k) plan will allow the business owner to make very large, tax-deductible contributions to the cash balance plan and potentially bring their AGI below the QBI caps.

SALT limits

Defined benefit plans will likely help high earners cope with new limits on state and local taxes (SALT). The 2017 tax law limits SALT deductions, including property taxes and state income taxes, to $10,000. This means someone who earned $5 million and lives in California will only be able to deduct $10,000 from their federal return rather than the roughly $600,000 that would have been deductible under the old law. High earners, especially those in high tax states, will be well advised to explore the possibility of reducing their taxable income through the use of defined benefit plans.

As always, we must note that the solutions discussed above are not appropriate for everyone. Please contact a Claris advisor to see if a cash balance plan is right for you.

Share Button

Where Has the Value Premium Gone?

As evidence-based investors, Claris and our clients follow decades of Nobel Prize-winning research and tilt investment portfolios toward long-term sources of higher expected returns. These sources, or premiums, were conclusively…
Read More.

Volatility Continues as Trade Tensions Remain High

Coming off years of strong investor confidence, volatility has become the name of the game. 2018 was a hard year for equity markets when, for the first time in almost…
Read More.

Pouring Cold Water on the Bucket Investing Strategy

The bucket strategy is a commonly used investment strategy, dividing a retirement portfolio into at least two different accounts. One account is invested in a more aggressive manner for future…
Read More.

Ask Claris: Why Do You Use Only One Mutual Fund Company to Manage Portfolios?

It’s not unusual for someone to ask us why we exclusively use one mutual fund company to manage our clients’ portfolios. The simple answer: it’s based on planning and implementation.…
Read More.

For Every Seller, There’s a Buyer

“Sellers were out in force on the market today after negative news on the economy.” It’s a common line in TV finance reports. But have you ever wondered who is…
Read More.

A Great Night for Baseball at our 7th Annual Client Appreciation Event

No rain, cool temps, good food, great company and top that off with a 5-3 win for the St. Louis Cardinals to hold their National League Wildcard spot! Our client…
Read More.